Shelter Island Country Club
Shelter Island Country Club is a historic golf facility on an island in Suffolk County, New York, established in 1901 and covering about 42 acres. The Colonial Revival clubhouse features a two-story wood-frame structure with gambrel roof and dormers, alongside a nine-hole golf course, driving range, and practice green.
The golf course was founded in 1901 by Wesley Smith, a groundskeeper and amateur architect, and is locally known as Goat Hill. It was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2009, recognizing its historical significance and architecture as important to the community.
The Flying Goat restaurant reflects a cherished local story tied to the island's character. Members and visitors use the club as a social gathering place where Shelter Island traditions are shared and celebrated through events and casual meetings.
The course is accessible via local roads and operates on a semi-private basis welcoming visitors for rounds of play. Facilities include a driving range, practice green, and clubhouse with the Flying Goat restaurant where you can relax before or after your game.
Seven of the nine holes feature blind shots where golfers cannot see the entire fairway or green, creating an unusually challenging layout on steep terrain with false flags. This primitive design makes it distinctly different from modern golf courses and appeals to players seeking authentic, unpredictable play.
The community of curious travelers
AroundUs brings together thousands of curated places, local tips, and hidden gems, enriched daily by 60,000 contributors worldwide.
