Manhattan Theatre

The Manhattan Theatre was located at 102 West 33rd Street in Midtown, featuring roughly 1,100 seats with modern architectural styling for its time. The building sat across from Greeley Square, making it a visible landmark in the theater district.

The building opened in 1875 as the Eagle Theatre and underwent major renovations in 1884 following a fire that damaged the structure. It operated until its demolition in 1909, spanning three decades of theatrical life.

The venue hosted authorized American premieres of Gilbert and Sullivan operas during the 1880s, with Patience becoming one of its most successful productions. These shows attracted audiences who sought out English musical theatre during that era.

Under Harrison Grey Fiske's direction, the venue operated first as a traditional playhouse before transitioning to film screenings in its final years. This shift reflects the changing entertainment preferences visitors and audiences experienced during that period.

After its demolition, the site became home to Gimbels department store, which was eventually transformed into the current Manhattan Mall. This succession shows how commercial uses and public spaces evolved in the neighborhood.

Location: Manhattan

Inception: 1875

Address: 102 West 33rd Street, New York, NY 10001

GPS coordinates: 40.74930,-73.98880

Latest update: December 12, 2025 14:40