First Presbyterian Church of Pennington, Victorian Gothic Revival church in Pennington, United States.

The First Presbyterian Church of Pennington stands as a red brick building on South Main Street displaying Gothic details such as pointed arches and ribbed vaults throughout its structure. The church includes spaces for gatherings and education, which the congregation uses for its regular activities.

The congregation was founded in 1709, anchoring its roots deep in colonial times. The building standing today was constructed in 1875 after the previous Gothic structure from 1847 was destroyed by fire.

The cemetery lies on the south side of the church, not around it, and is part of the 2011 National Register listing. The congregation began as the Hopewell Presbyterian Church in 1709, so the burial ground holds generations of local families.

The building sits in the town center at an easy-to-find location where visitors can discover it while walking through the streets. The grounds including the cemetery are open to visitors who wish to explore the gravestones and the surrounding area.

The 2011 National Register listing covers not only the 1875 red brick church but also the cemetery on its south side, so the graveyard is part of the designated historic property. The building itself was designed by architect James Bird and replaced an 1847 Gothic structure that burned in 1874.