Madison Square Presbyterian Church, New York City

Madison Square Presbyterian Church was a Gothic building located at Madison Avenue and 24th Street, created after two separate church congregations merged their communities. The structure rose prominently above the streetscape and held worshippers who came from across the neighborhood.

The building was constructed in the mid-1800s when two older church congregations joined together to form a stronger community. It was demolished in the early 1900s to make room for a major insurance company that wanted to expand its headquarters in the city.

The church served as a place where the local congregation gathered for both spiritual life and social concerns affecting their city. Pastors from this pulpit spoke out on matters that touched the lives of ordinary New Yorkers.

The building no longer stands at this location, so visitors can only trace its history where a modern office building now occupies the space. The site remains in the heart of Manhattan's business district, accessible and walkable from nearby neighborhoods.

Some of the church's stained glass windows and decorated doors were saved when the building was torn down and sent to museums around the city. These pieces survive as reminders of the fine craftsmanship that once adorned the interior spaces.

Location: New York

Inception: 1854

Architects: Richard M. Upjohn

GPS coordinates: 40.74160,-73.98750

Latest update: December 14, 2025 12:27