Church of the Nativity

The Church of the Nativity sits on Second Avenue in the East Village and blends modernist architectural forms with traditional church design. Built in 1970, the structure shapes the streetscape with its contemporary styling within this historic neighborhood.

The original Greek Revival structure was built in 1832 by prominent architects and was later converted to Catholic use. A major fire in 1912 destroyed the interior and organ, triggering extensive reconstruction of the building.

The church served as a gathering place for supporters of the Catholic Worker Movement, drawing people committed to social justice. The space carried a spirit of activism and community that continues to resonate in the neighborhood today.

The building is no longer active as a church and has been purchased by real estate interests, limiting visitor access. To experience the site, view the exterior from the sidewalk and appreciate the architectural details from street level.

The building underwent a striking transformation from a Presbyterian church to a Catholic parish after changing ownership in the 1840s. This conversion reflects the evolving religious and cultural composition of the neighborhood at that time.