Church of the Atonement

The Church of the Atonement is an Episcopal church building in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, constructed in the Gothic Revival style with white wooden exterior walls and board and batten siding. The structure features wooden shingles and stands as a small wooden chapel characteristic of 19th-century religious architecture in the rural Midwest.

The church was established in 1878 when the Diocese of Fond du Lac purchased an unfinished fisherman's house and converted it for religious use. This adaptive reuse of an existing structure became the foundation for the community's spiritual center during the area's early development.

The church serves as a gathering place for the Fish Creek community, drawing both year-round residents and seasonal visitors to Sunday services throughout summer. It maintains traditional Episcopal worship practices that reflect the area's long-standing religious heritage.

The church is located on Cottage Row and operates only during summer months since the building lacks heating. Plan your visit for the warmer season when the doors are open and services are held regularly.

The lumber for the church's construction came from a donation by Mrs. L. M. Griswold, wife of a local sawmill owner who generously contributed materials. This personal contribution from a prominent local family helped make the building possible.

Location: Gibraltar

Inception: 1878

Architectural style: Gothic Revival

Address: 9415 Cottage Row

GPS coordinates: 45.12809,-87.24942

Latest update: December 14, 2025 18:12