Hotel Margaret, early Brooklyn skyscraper
Hotel Margaret was a ten-story building in Richardsonian Romanesque style standing at the corner of Columbia Heights and Orange Street in Brooklyn Heights. Designed by Frank Freeman in 1889, it featured multicolored stones, rounded arches, heavy walls, and decorative terracotta details that gave the structure a solid yet intricately detailed appearance.
John Arbuckle, a wealthy coffee importer, commissioned the hotel in 1889 as a family enterprise and named it after his sister Margaret. The building remained Brooklyn's tallest structure for many years until a fire broke out during renovation work in 1980, completely destroying the structure.
Hotel Margaret was a gathering place for artists and writers who made Brooklyn their home, including the author Sigrid Undset and Betty Smith, who lived there while writing. The hotel was named after the sister of its owner John Arbuckle, giving the building a personal story that neighbors remembered.
The original hotel no longer exists, but the corner of Columbia Heights and Orange Street remains easy to locate and offers views of New York Harbor similar to those the hotel once provided. The site is part of walking tours through Brooklyn Heights and helps visitors understand this neighborhood's history through remaining fragments and neighbors' accounts.
The hotel's top floor featured a sun parlor with panoramic views across the city in every direction, where guests could oversee both Manhattan and Brooklyn's growing neighborhoods from above. This elevated retreat became so popular that it functioned as a landmark drawing visitors seeking bird's-eye perspectives of the expanding metropolis.
The community of curious travelers
AroundUs brings together thousands of curated places, local tips, and hidden gems, enriched daily by 60,000 contributors worldwide.
